After discovering their significant others are siblings, two resentful exes must spend Christmas under one roof while hiding their romantic history.

The holiday season often brings with it joy, family gatherings, and unexpected surprises. But in Our Little Secret (2024), directed by Stephen Herek, the surprises are of a hilariously awkward variety. This festive comedy combines witty writing, a stellar cast, and a delightfully uncomfortable premise to deliver a holiday film that’s both heartwarming and laugh-out-loud funny.
A Recipe for Holiday Chaos
The story revolves around two exes, portrayed by Lindsay Lohan and Ian Harding, who find themselves in a cringe worthy predicament. After a less than amicable breakup, their paths cross again when they discover their new significant others are siblings. To make matters worse, the exes are forced to spend Christmas under one roof with their intertwined families, all while keeping their romantic past a secret.
The setup is ripe for comedic misadventures, as the two characters navigate the holiday chaos while grappling with unresolved feelings and an ever growing pile of awkward moments. The comedic tension escalates as family traditions, nosy relatives, and holiday mishaps threaten to expose their shared history.
A Star Studded Cast Shines Bright
Lindsay Lohan, who continues her triumphant return to acting, delivers a charismatic performance as the sharp tongued and slightly jaded ex-girlfriend. Her comedic timing and knack for physical humor are perfectly matched with Ian Harding’s portrayal of the charming but equally flustered ex-boyfriend. Together, they create a dynamic that is both relatable and endlessly entertaining.
Adding to the hilarity is Kristin Chenoweth, who plays the meddling matriarch of the family. With her larger than life personality and impeccable comedic chops, Chenoweth steals every scene she’s in, delivering quippy one-liners and stirring up the family drama.
The supporting cast, including the oblivious siblings who unwittingly instigate the chaos, provides additional layers of humor and heart. Their innocence and enthusiasm for the holiday season contrast beautifully with the exes’ desperate attempts to maintain their charade.
Comedy with a Heartfelt Core
While Our Little Secret thrives on its comedic elements, it also weaves in themes of forgiveness, self discovery, and the true meaning of family. Beneath the laugh out loud scenarios and sharp dialogue lies a story about reconciling the past and embracing the present. The exes’ journey from resentment to mutual understanding is both touching and satisfying, offering a message of hope and growth that resonates during the holiday season.
Hailey DeDominicis script expertly balances humor and emotion, creating a narrative that feels fresh yet universally appealing. The holiday backdrop adds a layer of warmth and nostalgia, making the film an ideal watch for audiences seeking a mix of laughs and heartfelt moments.
A New Holiday Favorite
Our Little Secret is a delightful addition to the pantheon of holiday comedies, combining a unique premise with standout performances and sharp writing. Stephen Herek’s direction ensures a brisk, engaging pace, while the cast’s chemistry brings the story to life in a way that’s both hilarious and heartfelt.
Whether you’re a fan of holiday films, romantic comedies, or Lindsay Lohan’s irresistible charm, Our Little Secret is a must watch. It’s a story about love, family, and the beautiful messiness of both—a perfect way to celebrate the season.